Foreign Aid Risks Making Third World Countries Dependent on Handouts Official Review Finds

On the basis of the PCP, this newspaper volition clarify the major factors that undermine the effectiveness of strange assistance. These factors range from abuse, weak policies and fragile institutions in the recipient countries, on the one hand, and the intended goals of the donors, and lack of domestic knowledge of foreigner experts working in donor organizations in order to brand a change in the recipient countries, on the other (Monkam 2008; Lancaster 2007).

Corruption, weak policies, fragile institutions in the recipient countries and the ineffectiveness of foreign help

From the recipient side, corrupt regimes was given every bit an explanation of performance disappointment (Earth Bank 1998). This issue requires attending to become aware of and to identify a series of problems in the political and economic institutions, and even in public policies. These include political and social accountability, administrative systems and governmental hierarchy, and the commitment of public services in the recipient countries (De Haan 2009). Combating and reforming such regimes is considered to exist a hard task. In an attempt to overcome corrupt regimes, donor countries and organizations accept been persistently introducing hundreds of authorities programmes, and employed endless developmental measures, since the second half of the 20th century. Notwithstanding, such regimes remain equally reckless an obstacle as ever in the confront of achieving effective foreign aid programmes. Experimental testify indicate that complex problems inherent in such regimes prevented the cosmos of user-friendly conditions for necessary reform, and take even prevented these developmental measures being put to appropriate use.

A number of studies in this field have shown that strange aid programmes directed at poor countries accept created what can be called a 'fell circle'. Specifically, poor countries have become increasingly dependent on foreign aid and at the same fourth dimension reduced their efforts to bringing about market reforms that can promote public production and income taxes in other sectors. Instead, these poor countries spend fiscal aid on financing government expenditure, and funding non-productive consumer sectors (Bauer 2000). ^five

Referring to the Yemeni situation, nearly 95% of capital and operational expenditures of the government, as well equally other aspects of non-capital expenditures are covered past either foreign assist or oil revenues. In 1995 and 2012, Yemeni got foreign developmental commitments and strange help equal to US$eighteen billion. Parallel to that, the land's national revenue – particularly from oil product – constitutes about 75% of total national income. Yemen was (and will go along to exist) completely reliant on foreign assist every bit a driving force in the country'due south development. Republic of yemen is incapable of collecting taxes; statistics show that only 10% of the expected total amount of taxes was nerveless. This pct, which was collected by the central bank of Republic of yemen, is but from pensions and government contracts. There is no attempt to collect this kind of tax lack. Consequently, organizations concerned in tax collection plant a heavy operational burden on both land and society. Moreover, they are actually unemployment bearded within the administrative system of the country.

Another example comes from Jordan, where it received directly greenbacks strange assist of about The states$24 billion between 1970 and 2007. This aid aimed at bridging the gap of deficiency in the public budget, or was indirect greenbacks help offered through unlike programmes and projects. An agreement betwixt the Jordan Ministry of Planning and the donors, with regard to the unlike aspects of planning and implementing these programmes and projects, gives the donors the right to arbitrate straight in them. Thus, foreign assist is considered to be a crucial aspect of the Jordanian economic system where total foreign help constituted the highest proportion of fixed capital in 1975 at around 153\%, then retreated in 2003 to around 66\% of stock-still capital. Hashemite kingdom of jordan remains the country receiving the highest corporeality of foreign aid among the Arab countries including Arab republic of egypt, Yemen, Lebanon, Sudan and others. All these indications provide a clear and complete motion-picture show nearly the degree of Jordan'due south dependence on strange assistance, and the extent of weakness in economic policies that hinder developing the domestic resource of the country.

Therefore, developing policies of poor countries give a realistic understanding of the ineffectiveness of strange aid programmes, and even of how such policies hinder the development efforts introduced by the countries themselves. It is known that such policies were designed and fostered in any given guild under the influence of the 'political nature' of the ruling regime. Supporters of this perspective claim that the ineffectiveness of strange aid is a direct result of the 'tyrannical regimes' in most recipient countries. They claim that these tyrannical regimes do not protect human or civil rights and they fifty-fifty suffer from the absence of specialized and uncorrupted public administrations. Consequently, they are unable to use aid in an constructive way (Leftwich 1993, 2000).

An important book published by the political economist Francis Fukuyama, entitled Falling Backside: Explaining the Development Gap between Latin America and the Usa (2008), explains the nature of the development gap between the countries of Latin America (most of them are help recipients) and the United states. It traces the history of development over four centuries and gives a special focus on the last 50 years. The conclusion of this study claims that political and totalitarian regimes of well-nigh Latin American countries plant the main essence of the economic gap with the United States. These regimes, he claims, are keen to attain the maximum benefit of care for the ruling and long-lasting coalition in these countries, rather than working for the welfare of their societies. Some researchers accept concluded that tyrannical and totalitarian regimes deliberately adopt incorrect and short-term development policies; they thereby work against the effectiveness of foreign aid programmes. ^six

Both Boone (1996) and Bauer (2000) conclude that the miserable weather of the recipient countries of foreign aid programmes are not only a direct result of ineffective policies, but rather an outcome of the official 'devastating' policies adopted by tyrannical rulers of these helpless countries. For an in-depth agreement Bonne (1996) offers a practical analysis apropos the effectiveness of foreign aid programmes in 97 recipient countries. In this analysis, Boone distinguishes between three different political regimes: the neutral regime, the regime based on equality and the authorities of the elite. This third type is considered the most decadent ruling regime in expending the resources of the foreign assistance. The high rate of poverty emerges in countries ruled by such regimes that adopt devastating policies, and not for the reason of a shortage of economic and financial resources, as they claim.

Bauer (2000) presents a long list of these destructive policies, such as the persecution of the nearly productive groups, especially ethnic minorities (who were sometimes expelled), suppression of trade (sometimes accompanied with the devastation of the trading system), restrictions on capital flow and foreign companies, a wide range confiscation of property (including compulsory collective labour), voluntary and involuntary buy of strange companies that captivate rare and external majuscule (thus depriving the country from learning valuable skills and competencies), pricing policies that discourage agronomical production, forms of unneeded and costly support of unsustainable projects and activities (this includes the replacement of subsided imports), the imposing of specific economic measures, the negative effects of the restrictions of foreign contacts, and mobility procedures. The long list presented by Bauer of destructive policies cause a delay in newly constructive ideas (Bauer 2000; Boone 1996).

If but ane of the previous examples were to be practical to the Arab countries, information technology would be institute that almost Arab countries subsidize the prices of basic consumer goods by random policies. Such policies have resulted in the bankruptcy of the economic system of these countries and the devastation of both the agronomical and the industrial sectors, turning them into misfit sectors. For instance, Egypt, Jordan and Yemen ⁷ spend more than one-quarter of the national upkeep and v–vi\% of the total gross national production (GNP) on subsiding basic consumer products. Such conflicting policies have led primarily to the inability of the agricultural and industrial sectors to compete with the prices of imported products which are subsidized by the government. This has led to the bankruptcy and closure of many facilities. Furthermore, in recent years at that place has been no growth or development in either of these two important development sectors. Negative consequences and impacts of such policies are non confined to this level; rather information technology has opened the door to corruption with subsidized products being sold on the blackness marketplace and even exported to other countries at extremely expensive prices. This has created a heavy burden on the upkeep of the land, created deficits of different kinds, increased the internal and external debts, and produced mafia-like and unofficial economic networks that command the economy of the country. Terminal but non least, these policies have helped to create a fragile economic system in nearly Arab countries, putting them in an unstable position and making their people live in farthermost poverty.

The reasons backside these regimes that adopt destructive policies in order to continue their people in extreme poverty are numerous. Easterly (2007) argues that, firstly, the elitist political regimes frankly seek to reduce the productive capacity of the poor, so as not to be threatened by political activity in case the poor became more productive. Secondly, the selfish economic benefits of the corrupt ruling elite (the PCP) depend on encouraging the donors to allocate foreign aid on humanitarian grounds. The index of poverty in the recipient countries is the controlling indicator for the donors to classify foreign help to these countries. In other words, the elitist ruling regimes want their people to live in extreme poverty so they can describe donors' support. The duplicity of such regimes is that they seek more foreign financial resources to promote evolution and reduce poverty, yet they prefer destructive policies that create more misery for their people (Easterly 2007).

Treasury bills and brusk-term money bills are proficient examples of the destructive financial and economical policies in near Arab countries, especially the non-oil-rich ones. In spite of the wide controversy about the effectiveness of treasury bills being a governmental tool adopted every bit a monetary policy in case of emergency to create monetary stability by hitting a balance between coin supply and purchasing power, it has turned out to be a brusk-term policy. It is considered as an easy process to ensure the profits and capital value. Regardless of the exact theoretical indications of the monetary policy adopted by near Arab countries in presenting bids ranging from three months to one year, in either local or strange currencies, it has become clear that these countries managed to withdraw and relieve currency. Still, at that place is one condition necessary for the success of this monetary policy, namely the adequacy and effectiveness of the state to invest the cash to ensure the render of these capitals with profits to the beneficiaries whether they are institutions or individuals. In some countries such as Yemen, the turn a profit per centum reached a really massive ration of about 19\% of the total majuscule value. In fact, this cool monetary policy will not succeed in countries that are unable to invest their available resource; therefore, they volition be unable to invest treasury bills.

In virtually Arab countries, the consequences of the treasury bills policy are disastrous. For instance, in Yemen and Arab republic of egypt this monetary policy has led to the restriction of the private sector. These private sectors were engaged in achieving lucrative profits in investments rather than investing in the evolution projects required for the revival of the land's economic progress. The reduction of the risk of such individual sectors depends on the fact that the country is obliged to pay; otherwise the banking system would collapse on a general level. Recently, this state of affairs was compounded by the unstable political and security weather condition in the regions. Consequently, the individual sectors, banks and even individuals, and the decadent employees in public institutions, all opted for treasury bills as secure investment. Another facet of this disastrous monetary policy is the diverse methods of abuse by the unofficial determination makers in most Arab countries, in the framework of treasury bills, through borrowing from strange banks and investing in these treasury bills with high interest rates. These procedures, although they achieve massive profits, render countries unable to invest in unlike areas including foreign assets, and lead people impoverishment, and increment the proportion of internal debts to critical levels. In Yemen, for example, and according to the data of Yemen'south central bank, in 2014 the full internal debt reached about 300 trillion Yemeni riyals as a direct outcome of treasury bills. In Arab republic of egypt, the full internal debt reached its top in 2015 to a tape 99\% of gross domestic product (GDP), exceeding the bulwark of 2 trillion Egyptian pounds to a record 2.2 trillion Egyptian pounds (more than half the internal debt) to be paid to 15 Egyptian banks. These destructive policies are not confined to the economic sector; rather, they extend to all governmental sectors including the education sector, which is considered to be any given country'due south source of revival.

In a written report that focused on the persistence of the ruling aristocracy and the directly consequences of ruining the educational activity sector in Yemen, data were gathered that illustrate the furnishings of this particular kind of policy adopted past some ruling Arab recipient regimes (Easterly and Levine 1997). Figure 2 shows the link between the policy of survival and the policy of education. In such a link, the policy of survival has double-negative consequences on the education sector, on both domestic and national levels alike. On the domestic level, the ruling elite gave tribal sheikhs more influence over the education sector in order to weaken education outputs. Tribal sheikhs were given the right to manage schools and were appointed as local officials over the educational activity process. Information technology is known that tribal sheikhs have their own objectives; they are aware that a real educational process will lead to greater sensation, and vigilance among tribal men, that may affect their loyalty, and dependability. To prove this statement, the researcher fabricated a comparison betwixt the education outputs of the educational reforms in Republic of yemen in two different areas; the kickoff was controlled by strong tribal influence, the 2nd had a fairly frail and vulnerable tribal influence The results of these 2 areas differed considerably in both the quality and the quantity of the outputs. For example, the rates of main didactics enrolment in a region with stiff tribal influence were fairly low when compared with the other region; it recorded 80\% in the region with frail and vulnerable tribal influence (75\% for females, 84\% for males). Yet, but 48\% enrolled in primary education in the region with potent tribal influence, where lxx\% of the population lives. In 2008, the net enrolment charge per unit for females was 28\%, and 67\% for males in the region with strong tribal influence.

Lack of foreign help effectiveness in developing countries between a hammer and an anvil

Published online:

13 January 2016

Figure 2. Survival policy of the ruling elite and the reality of teaching in Yemen.

Source: Elayah (2008).

In return, the ruling aristocracy in Yemeni accept adopted many destructive policies on the domestic level to weaken the educational sector and to preclude the emergence of strong powers that might threaten their beingness. One of these policies is the creation of duality in didactics whereby there are three educational systems operating simultaneously: the official pedagogy arrangement, the scientific schools and the scientific institutes. These three different systems are in abiding competition with each other, with each 1 trying to undermine the others. This has concluded up weakening the educational process. 1 of the practices of weakening the educational process is the horizontal expansion of educational institutions by strange funding without ever contemplating the idea of creating and developing the required human resources in both the authoritative and educational cadres.

Figure 2 shows how the weak educational sector contributes to the survival of the ruling elite and their persistence in authority in two unlike strands:

• The weak educational arrangement is 1 of the techniques of the survival policy that enable the aristocracy to continue ruling without a unmarried threat from the didactics sector and thus prevent the emergence of other forces of ability.

• The graduates of this weak educational system volition be unqualified and, thus, will serve in forming a ring in the survival cycle in two different ways. Firstly, weak outputs of the educational sector will lead to the re-creation of the tribal organisation on the domestic level, and thereby strengthen the tribal sheikhs who will in plow lead to the formation of alliances on the national level with the ruling elite guaranteeing their survival in positions of authority. Secondly, these weak outputs will assistance in the cosmos of unqualified authoritative employees who help in the concatenation of the country's bureaucracy that will in return lead to the weakening of the country'south administrative sector. This second gene will threaten the survival of the ruling elite and their permanency in ruling positions, and fifty-fifty will foreclose the emergence of the forces of power. As mentioned above, the beingness of powerful institutions in the land volition straight threaten the survival policy of the ruling aristocracy. Therefore, the policy of survival and the process of educational activity remain intact through the repetition of the inputs and outputs on both the domestic and national levels.

• The tertiary cistron in adopting the destructive development policies, Easterly argues, is the ethnic diversity institute in recipient countries also every bit the lower level of education, political instability, inadequate infrastructure, and many other related factors associated with the slow cycle of development.

A model of ruling regimes in developing countries was presented by Migdal (1988), equally explained previously in the Yemeni case. He pointed out that indigenous diversity stands against the continuity of the ruling totalitarian elitist regimes. Therefore, such regimes provide political, economic and financial care for these ethnic groups for the sake of political mobilization, and, for this reason, preserve their alliance. Cohen (2006) introduces a type of applied study concerned with the human relationship betwixt ethnic diversity and the effectiveness of foreign aid in Kenya. He concludes that ethnic diversity has unforeseen influences on the formulation and implementation of development interventions in the framework of foreign assistance programmes. Cohen sees that in the fiscal year 1991–92 the regime of Republic of kenya approved the implementations of 654 development projects to exist funded by grants or loans presented by different donors. However, the actual number of the accustomed projects in that same twelvemonth was much less than the to a higher place-mentioned number. The reason behind such a contradiction is that both government officials and foreign experts from the donors' side all agreed to divide these projects to ensure that indigenous groups received a fair share of the foreign aid. Coinciding with this, the coalition members in Kenya have other incentives with regard to the local resource, and how to brand use of them in economical projects in tribal regions that ensure their loyalty. Cohen concludes that dictatorship regimes pursue the mobilization of the poor past dissimilar methods, including money; they also pursue the use of destructive development policies for the reorientation of foreign financial aid. ⁸

Problems with the self-centred targets of donors and ineffectiveness of strange assist

It is totally wrong to believe that the donors have the ability to impose reform atmospheric condition associated with the programmes of the strange aid by threatening to stop this assist in future, in the example of it not being used in the right way. However, from the PCP, near donors still connect their own cocky-centred interests, including those related to politics, strategy, trade, culture and ideology, with the probable granting of foreign aid. The essence of the problem lies in the fact that donors entertain potent intentions to accomplish these self-centred interests while paying picayune attention to the failure of strange help programmes. A widespread feeling about the ineffectiveness of foreign assistance programmes points to bear witness that these programmes frequently work against humanitarian and evolution objectives. This supposition goes farther, challenge that donors' cocky-centred interests assistance to undermine the outputs of the help and limit their effectiveness.

Lancaster (2007) describes the nature of the relationship betwixt the local actors in the donor countries and the foreign aid every bit a rather complex one. He presented a long list of actors and factors on dissimilar political and authoritative levels in the donor countries. Those actors could be, for instance, individuals or official organizations, or unofficial organizations. They have certain interests and targets in forming and implementing interventions in the process of strange aid in particular ways. These actors have their own guidelines and targets that hide some concerns. They know precisely where, when and in what style to use their influence to achieve their goals. Their goals and interests very oftentimes vary, and can influence the governments of the donor countries externally and on the international level. They tin, with the aid of the bilateral and multilateral agencies that run help interventions in the recipient countries, practise strong pressure on techniques and methods of foreign aid. In other words, in most cases, the objectives of foreign assistance policies are rooted and reflected in the nature of the domestic powers and forces in donor countries. These in plow tin can govern competing interests in controlling the aid offered to poor and developing countries (Olsson and Wohlgemuth 2003, Brainard and Chollet 2007).

Therefore, information technology is neither strange nor very surprising to discover that the objectives of the strange help cover the following considerations:

• Diplomatic interests (e.g., the establishment of a military machine basis, securing votes in the United Nations and supporting the preferred regimes).

• Security interests (eastward.k., preserving the national security of the donor countries within the framework of the fight confronting terror. This takes place in developing countries that are considered suitable for the growth and expansion of terror).

• Commercial interests (e.g., the provision of consign back up to donor countries' companies, with great accent on projects of high foreign currency profits).

Groups, which own sure commercial interests, always take advantage of foreign aid so as to raise their exports, and sometimes use foreign aid equally a means to seize much needed raw materials. Cultural interests ofttimes used to change organized religion and linguistic communication, or to alter values that may represent threats to Western countries (Hancock 1989). Furthermore, some of the public interest groups may support relief, development and other different purposes. These groups have a complex network of organizations to exert force per unit area on policy-makers, only like the agriculture producers, chambers of commerce, business associations, individual institutions, merchandise unions, churches, universities and other influential unofficial networks.

In the framework of international assist to Yemen, i may find that obsession with security constitutes a major consideration, simply because Yemen is seen equally fertile ground for the growth of terror. This stems from two factors: the first is that Republic of yemen is a delicate land; the second is that information technology lacks command over its borders. Figure 3 illustrates that the financial obligations of the donor countries increased afterwards the attacks of 9/11. We can therefore conclude that donors are very keen to uphold their ain national interests and security. Hence, donor countries decided to distribute assistance co-ordinate to these 2 factors. The total corporeality of donor commitments made to Yemen at the conference in The Hague in 1996 was U.s.a.$500 one thousand thousand. It was largely increased after the attacks of 9/xi. At the Paris conference in 2002, the total amount of the donor commitments reached US$2300 meg. In 2006, at the London conference, the corporeality increased to United states$5700 1000000. This increase should be seen in the context of the increasing threats of Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula with Republic of yemen equally its centre. In 2012, at the New York conference, foreign commitment to Yemen was increased to reach Usa$7800 million. This increase reflects the exerted efforts to restore stability in Yemen after the events of the Arab Leap in 2011.

Lack of strange aid effectiveness in developing countries betwixt a hammer and an anvil

Published online:

13 Jan 2016

Figure 3. Aggregate book of donor commitments to Yemen, 1995–2012 (US$ millions).

Figure three. Amass book of donor commitments to Yemen, 1995–2012 (US$ millions).

With respect to the relationship between the United States and Arab republic of egypt, it is widely known that this human relationship is securely rooted in both security and war machine issues, is crucial to American national security and its policies in the region, is interconnected with the Arab–Israeli disharmonize, and even with the guarantee of the oil supply from the Gulf countries and Saudi Arabia. Notwithstanding, we are concerned here in this article with the human relationship between the United States and Egypt.

Information technology is true that Egypt receives huge economical aid from the United States, recorded at US$800 million in 1980, merely decreased in 2015 to only United states of america$250 million. The United states is considered to be the largest and simply trading partner with Arab republic of egypt, and the 2nd largest investor in Egypt. Prior to 2011, Egypt was the largest recipient of US foreign assist in the Eye E and Due north Africa (MENA). However, the United States nonetheless sticks to the policies of the donor countries in serving its national economy before serving the economy of the recipient land. About 70% of American investments in Cairo are directed at the oil and gas sectors to obtain the much-needed raw materials. Hence, new channels of investments in other sectors were initiated. These new channels aid in increasing productive employment in Egypt as well as pushing the development wheel. Moreover, Egypt is considered to be a large market for American products in all areas. Egypt is a consumer land with a huge population estimated at 100 million individuals. In 2013, the level of United states imports to Egypt reached Usa$vii billion, mostly in the agronomical and consumer areas. In this context, Thana'a Abdel Allah (2006) concluded that every American dollar spent as aid to Egypt will return 10 times equally many dollars to the American economic system.

Fifty-fifty when some donors are set to carelessness the to a higher place-mentioned interests while presenting foreign aid, there will nonetheless be the trouble with the bureaucracy of the agents that run aid programmes. This has generated a lucrative business from the aid programmes. These agents contend most the necessity of continuing this business because of how assisting it is. According to Hancock (1989), programme aid has go nothing more than than a deal between bureaucrats at the expense of others, done by intermediaries and brokers – 'poverty employees' equally Hancock calls them – hence, the people the assistance is concerned with are overlooked. It needs to be understood that the taxpayers in the rich countries genuinely intended that aid assistance be directed at the deserving poor in the south, and that aid was non intended for intermediaries, brokers and agents to build businesses for themselves from it.

Strange aid is really a very lucrative and easy business for those who run these programmes. The income of workers in these programmes is adamant in accordance with the following principle. Salaries of international organizations' employees should be high plenty to attract competitive experts to run these programmes finer. Therefore, these salaries exceed the salaries of loftier-level staff in the richest country on earth, namely the United States. This does not to say that it is non preferable to attract experts with high salaries. Such a policy can, withal, open doors to greedy souls taking advantage of the suffering of the poor equally a justification for their greed, and without being attentive to the damage that tin can take identify with regard to aid in both national and international levels. The experts' lack of local knowledge of the target countries that may influence the effectiveness of the evolution process tin can be a large result. This stems from the complexity and diverseness of the environment of the recipient countries. It is, therefore, important to shed a lite on the lessons that need to exist learned on bug that can impact the performance level of the donor countries and organization responsible for planning and managing evolution projects (Elayah 2014).

Inevitably, if the nature of the continuously irresolute local environment is non understood, it volition not be possible to estimate the local bug effectively. Finally, the adoption of any given evolution model may appear to be contributing to solving the problems of a given society. Nonetheless, later on a while, the adopted method may announced to be remote from reality because new local perspectives may announced with regard to sure issues. Alternatively, the method may not be able to reflect the real problems of the lodge, especially given that development problems have various perspectives. Therefore, most aid programmes may not suit the target tasks. This may be due to foreign experts being employed who are unacquainted with the nature of the local environment with all its social, political, and administrative complexities (Brinkerhoff 2005, Carlsson and Wohlgemuth 2007).

This situation of a cognition shortage in the framework of foreign aid has resulted in negative consequences for both donors and recipients. The orientations of foreign experts and administrators in the design and management of the development projects has hands become biased towards their countries of origin. Information technology may likewise even be that these orientations were derived from other recipient countries in which they had previously worked. Moreover, a number of these experts cannot be aware of the various development methods that should be applied in countries that are different from their own, but because of a lack of knowledge, inadequate time to get acquainted with the local environment, the real level of demand and the extent of issues in recipient countries (Elayah 2014).

In facing such situations, some donors have adopted international models and strategies to reorganize the way of encouraging change in the target countries, whether through economic, autonomous or institutional reforms. The idea backside these international models is to apply a planning and administrative framework to foreign aid projects; a frame that fits all. Because of the diversity in the social, economic and political nature of each country, it is believed that this framework may be successful in one country, but may not have positive results in others (Easterly 2002). For example, the strategy of the fast track to generalize preliminary education was applied in most developing countries such every bit Pakistan, Yemen, Kenya, Tajikistan, Nigeria, Cameron and others. It seems that such planning and administrative frameworks in all these countries are the same to some extent. If nosotros agree that the experience of administrative and financial decentralization has succeeded in one of the Eastern Europe countries, or in one of the Latin American countries (Brazil), donor countries should in return agree that the inputs and methods of reformation and development take not been beneficial in Yemen (Elayah 2014).

clewiscardearty.blogspot.com

Source: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/17550912.2015.1124519

Share this post